pokıto
Get the appGet

All rules · B1 · 6 min

Pero vs. sino

adding a second idea vs. correcting a 'no'

perobut · adds a second idea

sinobut rather · replaces after no

In short

pero adds a second idea that pulls against the first: Es caro, pero me gusta. sino only comes after a negative and puts the right thing in place of what you've just denied: No es rojo, sino azul. Before a conjugated verb it becomes sino que.

Examples

  • pero
  • El apartamento es pequeño, pero tiene mucha luz.

    The flat is small, but it gets lots of light.a second idea

  • Quería ir, pero no tenía tiempo.

    I wanted to go, but I didn't have time.an obstacle

  • No es caro, pero no me gusta.

    It isn't expensive, but I don't like it.a no, but nothing corrected

  • sino
  • No es rojo, sino azul.

    It isn't red, it's blue.correcting

  • No vive en Madrid, sino en Valencia.

    She doesn't live in Madrid but in Valencia.not here, there

  • No lo compró, sino que lo alquiló.

    He didn't buy it; he rented it.sino que + verb

  • No solo habla inglés, sino también chino.

    She speaks not only English but also Chinese.not only… but also

Forms

first partsecond part
peroEs caro,pero me gusta.
peroNo es caro,pero no me gusta.
sinoNo es caro,sino barato.
sino queNo lo compró,sino que lo alquiló.
no solo… sinoNo solo canta,sino que también baila.

Key points

  1. sino: only after a negative

    sino corrects a negative: the first part says what isn't so, the second gives what is. It needs a no (or nunca, nadie…) before it; without one, sino doesn't fit.

    No quiero té, sino café.

  2. A no isn't enough: is it a swap?

    A negative doesn't automatically call for sino. Ask whether the second part takes the place of what you denied. If both things are true together, it's pero.

    No hace sol, pero hace calor.

  3. sino que before a verb

    When the correction has its own conjugated verb, say sino que. Before a noun, an adjective, a place or an infinitive, plain sino is enough: No quiero salir, sino descansar.

    No me llamó, sino que me escribió.

  4. Not only… but also

    To add something bigger on top, say no solo A, sino también B (not only A but also B). With a verb in the second half: sino que también. 'No solo… pero también' is a common slip.

    No solo es barato, sino también rápido.

  5. One 'but', two words

    English says 'but' for both. If you can say 'not X but rather Y' or 'not X, Y instead', it's sino; if 'but' means 'however', it's pero.

    No es mi hermano, sino mi primo.

Check yourself

No voy en autobús, ___ en tren.

perosino

Show the answer

No voy en autobús, sino en tren.

the train replaces the bus after no → sino

Estoy cansada, ___ voy a ir a la fiesta.

perosino

Show the answer

Estoy cansada, pero voy a ir a la fiesta.

no negative to correct → pero

Read first: Ser vs. estar

Practise it in Pokito.

12 questions on this rule in the app, and every miss comes back until it sticks.

Download on the App StoreiPhone · iOS 17 or later